Best Pregnancy Safe Cream Cheese (Updated 2026 Guide)

Updated July 13, 2026

The Answer

Cream cheese is generally a moderate risk dairy choice during pregnancy: choose products made with pasteurized milk and cream, and keep them properly refrigerated. Of 788 products we reviewed, 609 received an A grade, while eight received a D or F.

The main pregnancy consideration is avoiding cream cheese made from raw, unpasteurized milk. Formulations also vary: some contain synthetic colors, added sweeteners, alcohol, cured meat ingredients, or concentrated seaweed ingredients that warrant avoidance or moderation based on the amount and frequency consumed.

Pregnancy Safe is 100% independent and research driven. No companies pay to promote or sponsor products.

What's Safe

  • A label that explicitly lists pasteurized milk, pasteurized cream, or pasteurized milk and cream
  • A short ingredient list centered on milk or cream, cheese culture, salt, and common stabilizers
  • Plain or simply flavored varieties without synthetic colors or added sweeteners
  • Sealed packaging that is refrigerated, within its use by date, and free from damage
  • An A or B+ grade when comparing formulations; 737 of the 788 products we reviewed fell into these grades

What to Avoid

  • Cream cheese made with raw or unpasteurized milk
  • Products containing alcohol, especially when the amount remaining in the food is unknown
  • Frequent choices containing red 40, blue 1, or unspecified artificial color
  • Products with high fructose corn syrup, particularly if they contribute regularly to high added sugar intake
  • Formulations containing sodium nitrite from cured meat or fish ingredients
  • Concentrated seaweed or kelp ingredients, including seaweed and kelp extract kelp extract, because iodine content can vary widely

Most Common Ingredients in Cream Cheese Products

We analyzed 788 cream cheese products. Here are the most common ingredients, ranked by how often they appear:

salt
94%
cheese culture
65%
pasteurized milk and cream
62%
xanthan gum
44%
carob bean gum
44%
guar gum
43%
stabilizers
22%
natamycin
21%
water
21%
natural flavor
21%
citric acid
17%
sugar
17%

Ingredients to Watch Out For in Cream Cheese

These are the most common flagged ingredients across 788 cream cheese products we analyzed.

red 40

CAUTION

Red 40 is a synthetic red food dye used in processed foods, drinks, candies, and some medicines. Has limited human pregnancy data and is allowed at regulated food additive levels, but child neurobehavior concerns and high dose animal findings make frequent high dye intake worth limiting. Red 40 is a synthetic food dye with limited human pregnancy data. Regulated food level exposure has not been shown to cause fetal harm, but high dose animal findings and child neurobehavior concerns support limiting frequent intake of heavily dyed cream cheese.

Found in 22 of 788 products (3%)

artificial color

CAUTION

Artificial color is a broad class of added synthetic color additives used in foods medicines and cosmetics. Has limited pregnancy specific outcome data; regulated incidental exposure is generally low concern but some dyes have child behavior allergy or regulatory caveats. Artificial color is a broad label that may cover one or more synthetic color additives. Pregnancy specific outcome data are limited, so occasional regulated food exposure is a different scenario from frequent intake; an uncolored cream cheese avoids this uncertainty.

Found in 8 of 788 products (1%)

blue 1

CAUTION

Blue 1 is a certified synthetic blue food color used in candies, drinks, frostings, cereals, and some medicines. Has limited human pregnancy data; regulated food use is not shown to cause fetal harm, but high dose animal neurobehavior findings and child sensitivity concerns support minimizing frequent exposure. Blue 1 is a synthetic blue food color with limited human pregnancy data. Regulated food use has not been shown to cause fetal harm, but high dose animal findings and sensitivity concerns support minimizing frequent exposure.

Found in 8 of 788 products (1%)

high fructose corn syrup

CAUTION

High fructose corn syrup is an added sweetener used in drinks and processed foods. Is not a known teratogen at occasional food amounts, but high added sugar intake can displace nutrients and raise gestational diabetes and metabolic concerns. High fructose corn syrup is an added sweetener, not a known teratogen at occasional food amounts. Frequent or high intake can increase overall added sugar exposure, displace nutrient dense foods, and contribute to metabolic concerns during pregnancy.

Found in 8 of 788 products (1%)

dill weed

AVOID

Dill weed is a cannabis product exposure containing THC, CBD, or other cannabinoids. Is associated with low birth weight, preterm birth, small for gestational age infants, and possible infant cannabinoid exposure through breast milk. Dill weed is the culinary leaf of the dill plant, not cannabis. The risk rationale associated with this category entry does not establish harm from culinary dill itself, so pregnancy risk from normal food amounts remains uncertain rather than proven; concentrated dill supplements would be a separate exposure.

Found in 5 of 788 products (1%)

horseradish

CAUTION

Horseradish is a pungent root used in condiments and herbal preparations. Is generally compatible at normal condiment amounts but should be avoided in medicinal products or large regular doses due to limited pregnancy data and possible uterine and irritant effects. Horseradish is a pungent root used as a food flavoring. Normal condiment amounts are generally compatible with pregnancy, while medicinal preparations or large regular doses should be avoided because pregnancy data are limited and irritant or uterine effects are possible.

Found in 4 of 788 products (1%)

seaweed

CAUTION

Seaweed is edible marine algae used in sushi, soups, snacks, powders, and kelp supplements. Can contain highly variable iodine, with high dose brown seaweed or kelp products and hijiki arsenic exposure requiring caution in pregnancy. Seaweed can contribute iodine, but the amount varies substantially by species and serving size. Frequent intake of high iodine brown seaweed, kelp products, or hijiki can create iodine or arsenic concerns, so ordinary food servings should not be equated with concentrated powders or supplements.

Found in 3 of 788 products (0%)

sodium nitrite

CAUTION

Sodium nitrite is a curing salt and preservative used mainly in cured meats and some cured fish. Is regulated at low food additive levels, but frequent cured or processed meat intake has limited observational pregnancy concerns; cyanide antidote and contaminated water exposures are separate issues. Sodium nitrite is a curing preservative used mainly in cured meat and some cured fish. Low regulated food additive exposure differs from frequent processed food intake, for which observational pregnancy concerns are limited; cream cheese containing cured ingredients is best kept occasional.

Found in 3 of 788 products (0%)

How Do Cream Cheese Products Stack Up?

We graded 788 cream cheese products for pregnancy safety. 609 received an A grade.

A
609 (77%)
B
128 (16%)
C
43 (5%)
D
3 (0%)
F
5 (1%)

Best Pregnancy Safe Cream Cheese

We found 20 pregnancy safe options. Here are some top picks.

Grade Product Brand
A Cream Cheese Philadelphia
A Happy Farms Whipped Cream Cheese Spread 8 Oz Happy Farms
A Original Whipped Cream Cheese Spread, Original Kroger
A Original Cream Cheese Spread Philadelphia
A Kroger, Original Cream Cheese

Cream Cheese to Avoid During Pregnancy

These popular products received low grades due to flagged ingredients.

Grade Product Brand
F Cream Cheese With Smoked Salmon
F Cream Cheese With Smoked Salmon, Cream Cheese
F Cream Cheese, Cream Shoprite
D Cream Cheese
D Cali Cream Cheese Roll Qbr, Cali Cream Cheese

Your Questions Answered

Can you eat cream cheese when pregnant?

Yes, cream cheese made from pasteurized milk and cream can generally be eaten during pregnancy. Check the package rather than assuming every product is pasteurized, especially with homemade, imported, farm made, or artisanal cheese. Keep it refrigerated and do not use it after spoilage or unsafe handling.

Can I eat a bagel with cream cheese while pregnant?

A bagel with pasteurized cream cheese is generally an appropriate pregnancy choice. Make sure the spread has been kept cold and has not sat out for an extended period. If it includes smoked fish, cured meat, alcohol, or other added ingredients, assess those components separately.

Why does pasteurization matter for cream cheese?

Pasteurization reduces harmful microorganisms in milk before the cheese is made. Pregnancy guidance for dairy focuses on avoiding raw milk and products made from it. The word “soft” alone does not determine whether cream cheese is suitable; the milk source and handling matter.

Are flavored cream cheeses safe during pregnancy?

They can be, provided the dairy is pasteurized and the product has been stored safely. Read the full ingredient list because flavored versions may add synthetic colors, high fructose corn syrup, alcohol, cured meat or fish ingredients, or concentrated seaweed. The relevant risk depends on the specific ingredient, amount, and frequency of consumption.

Should I avoid cream cheese with food coloring?

Pregnancy specific human data for red 40, blue 1, and broad artificial color blends are limited. Regulated food level exposure has not been established as a fetal hazard, but animal high dose findings and concerns about sensitivity or child behavior support limiting frequent exposure. Choosing an uncolored variety is a simple way to reduce exposure without avoiding cream cheese altogether.

Is cream cheese with herbs safe during pregnancy?

Ordinary culinary herbs in food are different from concentrated extracts, supplements, or medicinal doses. Horseradish is generally compatible in normal condiment amounts, but large regular or medicinal amounts have limited pregnancy data and possible irritant effects. For any unusual herbal formulation, check the ingredient amount and avoid treating a flavored spread as evidence that a concentrated herbal dose is safe.

How Do We Score Products for Pregnancy Safety?

We analyze each product's ingredients and category to flag known risks and provide cautionary notices for general category safety concerns.

People Also Checked

See our full guide to cheese during pregnancy.

References

  1. https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/rawmilk/index.html
  2. https://www.hfpappexternal.fda.gov/scripts/fdcc/index.cfm?id=FDCRed40&set=ColorAdditives
  3. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter I/subchapter A/part-74/subpart A/section-74.340
  4. https://www.fda.gov/food/color additives information consumers/tracking food industry pledges remove petroleum based food dyes
  5. https://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/1327